Modern Social Science Research
Modern Social Science Research. 2025; 5: (7) ; 10.12208/j.ssr.20250269 .
总浏览量: 132
南京工业大学 江苏南京
*通讯作者: 方辰,单位:南京工业大学 江苏南京;
文章从阐释正当防卫的概念和构成要件入手,通过对“于欢案”的案情分析,结合国内外有关不法侵害紧迫性主要观点,试图分析我国现行立法及司法实践中有关不法侵害紧迫性的规定与认定存在的适用性、规范性等不足,并从正当防卫的概念和构成要件、“于欢案”的案情介绍、该案中不法侵害紧迫性的讨论、国内外观点问题等方面提出一些完善对策,以期我国正当防卫制度的刑法价值得以有效彰显。
This article begins by explaining the concept and elements of justifiable defense. By analyzing the case of Yu Huan, it combines domestic and international perspectives on the urgency of unlawful aggression to examine the applicability and standardization of the provisions and recognition of the urgency of unlawful aggression in China's current legislation and judicial practice. It also proposes several improvement measures from the perspectives of the concept and elements of justifiable defense, the case details of Yu Huan, the discussion on the urgency of unlawful aggression in the case, and the issues of domestic and international viewpoints, aiming to effectively highlight the criminal law value of China's justifiable defense system.
[1] 张明楷.正当防卫的原理及其运用——对二元论的批判性考察[J].环球法律评论,2018,40(02):51-76.
[2] 周光权.论持续侵害与正当防卫的关系[J].法学,2017, 425(04):3-11.
[3] 孙凤荣.正当防卫制度的适用现状与制度完善[J].天津法学,2019 ,35 (02):87-91.
[4] 陈兴良.正当防卫:以刑民比较为视角的规范诠释[J].交大法学,2022,43(05):5-15.
[5] 张明楷.刑法学[M].北京:法律出版社.2016.
[6] 陈兴良.正当防卫如何才能避免沦为僵尸条款——以于欢故意伤害案一审判决为例的刑法教义学分析[J].法学家,2017(05):89-104+178.
[7] 陈兴良.正当防卫教义学的评析与展开[J].中国刑事法杂志,2021,No.200(02):3-29.
[8] See State v. Norman,89 N.C.App.384-389,366S.E.2d 586-589.(N.C.Ct.App.1988).
[9] 劳东燕.正当防卫的异化与刑法系统的功能[J].法学家,2018(05):76-90+193-194.
[10] 金霍伊泽尔.刑法总论教科书[M].北京:北京大学出版社.2015.